On New Year’s Eve, we went to a potluck dinner party to kick off the evening. We were seated at the table with a gentleman who described himself as the oldest parent of all the children in his daughter’s class. The daughter, age six, was in the other room watching a DVD on a portable player. The father told us that his little girl is not allowed to watch TV, that they do not own a television and that they carefully control every video she’s ever seen. At the moment, she was watching National Velvet. Mostly, the list included musicals which of course, puts the majority of her movie intake at films created between 1940 and 1970.
The most hilarious concession the father shared was that, concerned by their daughter’s lack of experience in diversity (ah, Charlottesville*) they rented from Netflix a season of The Cosby Show. The idea of The Cosby Show as an example of diversity still has me chuckling.
My own philosophies about television and children stem from a childhood balanced with movies, TV in moderation, live musicals, plays and lots of reading. TV is such a part of our culture; whether you’re a fan or not, it’s there and provides the backstory to pop culture references that will be lost on anyone who hasn’t logged the requisite four hours of TV per day. We know, of course, that kids who watch too much TV can be overweight, anti-social, have ADD and display violent tendencies. Thanks to TiVo, they’re watching less commercials; the American Academy of Pediatrics estimates that kids see 200,000 commercials per year. I’m more against the commercials than the programming, most of the time.
It’s really not that unusual for parents to set limits — almost every parent I know sets limits and has kids who are encouraged to play outside more often. It’s the elimination that gives me pause. This strategy makes the forbidden more attractive; look for mass amounts of TV binging as soon as that six-year-old is able; years spent “catching up” on all she may have missed.
I wonder, however, with the “approved” list of movies whether she’s on a diet of two musicals a day, whether she’s come to expect people to dance and sing in banks and strolling down the street. I wonder if she’s waiting to be asked to the barn raising when she’s older.
I’m not saying there’s anything wrong with the approach these parents are taking; it’s a personal parental decision. I just don’t know if it does any good, in the long run.
How have you dealt with TV and your kids?
*Follow this link for a very interesting article about diversity at the University of Virginia.